web analytics

Please fill in form fields.







days

track from:
   





The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu-ray Review

Posted July 31st, 2013 by Lawrence D. Devoe, MD

colon ring blu ray cover 253x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

Mouse-over Cover Art for Details

Click thumbnails for high-resolution 1920X1080p screen captures

(The below Blu-rayDefinition.com screen captures were taken directly from the Blu-ray Disc and losslessly compressed in the PNG format. There should be no loss of picture quality with this format. All screen captures should be regarded only as an approximation of the full capabilities of the Blu-ray format.)

The Film

rating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating 5 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

title2 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

The C Major group must have been reading my mind when they decided to release this Blu-ray disc featuring one of my favorite cities, opera houses and operatic composers. But The Colón Ring is less about an opera performance and more about overcoming incredible obstacles along the way. This documentary by Hans Christoph von Bock chronicles the attempt by Katharina Wagner (Richard Wagner’s great-granddaughter) to reduce the mammoth cycle Der Ring des Nibelungen from its usual 16-plus hours, spread over four operas on separate days, to a 7-hour condensation that does not compromise the artistic integrity of this masterpiece. Further, this project was to be done, not in Europe or the United States where Ring cycles are regularly performed, but in Buenos Aires, Argentina, blessed with a magnificent theater, but not one known for its Wagner.

wagner 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

In the course of this film, we get to know many of the singers, music preparers, conductor Cord Garben (who also created the performing version), and director Valentina Carrasco. What adds to the suspense and excitement is the race against time, particularly since a number of important participants, including the original director, changed or dropped out with little warning before the new work’s premiere.

Video Quality                                                                                               

rating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating 0 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

House 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

Given the varied provenance of the visual sources, there are considerable differences in the properties of the final film. Fortunately, with the few exceptions that look like old home movies, the film and video sections are quite good.

Audio Quality

rating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating 0 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

carrasco 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

Documentaries are not usually known for their great sound but this one has crisp dialogue and the intermittent musical snippets are very well reproduced in both soundtrack versions.

Supplemental Materials

rating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating 0 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating 0 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating 0 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating 0 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

farewell 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

Trailers, trailers, trailers and a slender program booklet with a background essay on this operatic production.

The Definitive Word

Overall:

rating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Reviewrating 0 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

all1 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

Aside from its considerable reduction in performance time, Director Carrasco’s politically charged reconceptualization of Wagner’s Ring Cycle may not appeal to some viewers. However, given the universality of the operas’ themes, there is ample precedence for other revisionist approaches. The excitement of live performance is the uncertainty of its final product. Here we get a relatively unvarnished view of the entire creative process. Given the diverse nationalities of the participants and the potential for frequent tower of babel situations, the fact that everything came together is nothing short of a miracle.

teatro 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

The brilliance of this documentary, and it is brilliant, is how it captures the inchoate process of rethinking iconic works that we have had for more than a century. Films like this are few and far between, considering the brilliant editing, the production constraints, and the obstacles in the way. I am reminded of the incredible Werner Herzog film, Fitzcarraldo, that depicted an opera-lover who goes to the literal ends of the earth to recreate his dream in the middle of a jungle. Whether or not this film will get viewers to go the full route and seek out the three Blu-ray set of the entire production (I hope that it will), The Colón Ring is a vibrant testimonial to art overcoming all odds. Highly recommended.

Additional Screen Captures

rehearse 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

sieg 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

rhinemaids 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

cord 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

maids2 600x338 The Colón Ring: Wagner in Buenos Aires Blu ray Review

Tags: C Major, Classical Music, Documentary, Opera, The Colon Ring, Wagner