web analytics
Fandango Now Tickets for AMC Theatres!

Please fill in form fields.







days

track from:
   





Ef: A Tale of Melodies — Complete Collection Blu-ray Review

Posted March 7th, 2012 by Brandon A. DuHamel

ef ataleofmelodies 267x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewunited states flag orb icon Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

  • Aspect Ratio: 1.78:1
  • Video Codec: AVC/MPEG-4
  • Resolution: 1080p/24 (23.976Hz)
  • Audio Codec: Japanese DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Stereo, English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Stereo
  • Subtitles: English
  • Region: A (Region-Locked)
  • Rating: TV-MA (DS)
  • Discs: 2 (2 x Blu-ray)
  • Run Time: 300 Mins.
  • Studio: Sentai Filmworks
  • Blu-ray Release Date: March 20, 2012
  • List Price: $69.98

Purchase Ef: A Tale of Melodies — Complete Collection on Blu-ray at CD Universe

Shop for more Blu-ray titles at Amazon.com

Overall
rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 5 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review
The Series
rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review
Video Quality
rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review
Audio Quality
rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 5 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review
Supplemental Materials
rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Click thumbnails for high-resolution 1920X1080p screen captures

(All Blu-rayDefinition.com screen captures are lightly compressed with lossy JPEG at 100% quality setting and are meant as a general representation of the content. They do not fully reveal the capabilities of the Blu-ray format)

-

The Series

rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 04 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

In Ef: A Tale of Melodies all the characters from the first installment of this anime adaptation of the visual novel, Ef- A Fairy Tale of the Two, return, but the focus now shifts to a different set of characters. Now the story zooms in on Renji’s neighbor Kuze who has been spending time with Renji’s cousin teenage cousin Mizuki. The two begin to fall in love, but Kuze has a terrible secret – a fatal heart condition that will soon end his life and he doesn’t want to leave with ties to the world. Meanwhile, Yuu Himura, Kuze’s longtime friend, is remembering his teenage love Yuko Amamiya, and through a series of flashbacks, the story of their ill fated love is told. Yuu, who still carries the weight of his love for her on his shoulders, can never be free unless he can find some closure in the present day – can her love reach him across time? It’s a story of love, loss, and hope with intertwined characters and developments.

Unlike the first series, Ef- A Tale of Memories, I found this one to be awfully difficult to follow,  somewhat ponderous and ultimately predictable in its storyline. While the animation is still quite compelling – beautiful use of lighting and color – the character development didn’t move me at all here, making this a disappointing second part to this franchise.

Video Quality

rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 02 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

It’s nearly impossible to find fault with anything in this AVC/MPEG-4 1080p/24 encodement of Ef: A Tale of Melodies from Sentai Filmworks. The animation is as pure and sharply detailed as one would imagine the creators intended. Apart from some color banding that looks to be part of the original animation rather than a consequence of the compression, there are no artifacts or visual distractions to speak of.

Audio Quality

rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 5 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 03 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

While the original Japanese mix and English dub in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Stereo don’t allow for as immersive an experience as a surround mix would have, they are both rather strong, solid experiences providing clean dialogue, a good sense of directionality, and nice dynamics.

Supplemental Materials

rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 05 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

There’s nothing here, really, besides the typical clean animations and additional trailers from Sentai.

The supplements:

The Definitive Word

Overall:

rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 5 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 06 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

I thought A Tale of Melodies would be as moving as A Tale of Memories, but it wasn’t. Ultimately the unnecessary complexity and trivial nature of some of the character developments left me feeling cold. It’s a beautiful production that didn’t live up to its potential.

-

Ef A Tale of Melodies 07 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 08 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 09 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 10 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 11 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 12 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 13 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 14 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 15 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 16 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 17 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 18 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 19 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Ef A Tale of Melodies 20 600x338 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

-

Purchase Ef: A Tale of Melodies — Complete Collection on Blu-ray at CD Universe

Shop for more Blu-ray titles at Amazon.com

Overall
rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 5 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review
The Series
rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review
Video Quality
rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review
Audio Quality
rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 5 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review
Supplemental Materials
rating Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewrating 0 Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

-

facebook Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Reviewtwitter Ef: A Tale of Melodies    Complete Collection Blu ray Review

Join the Discussion on Our Forum

Pin It
Share on Tumblr

Tags: 1080p/24, Animation, Anime, AVC/MPEG-4, Drama, DTS-HD Master Audio, Ef: A Tale of Melodies -- Complete Collection, Romance, Section 23 Films, Sentai Filmworks