web analytics

Please fill in form fields.







days

track from:
   





Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu-ray Review

Posted August 7th, 2009 by Brandon A. DuHamel

112 BD box 348x490 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Reviewunited states flag orb icon Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

  • Aspect Ratio: 1.85:1
  • Video Codec: AVC/MPEG-4
  • Resolution: 1080p/24
  • Audio Codec: French/English LPCM 2.0 (48kHz/24-bit)
  • Subtitles: English
  • Region: A
  • Discs: 1
  • Studio: Criterion
  • Release Date: August 18, 2009
  • List Price: $39.98
Purchase Playtime on Blu-ray from CD Universe 17927692 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review  Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray ReviewPurchase Playtime on Blu-ray from Best Buy Shop with us for more Blu-ray titles at Amazon.com
Overall
rating4 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review
The Film
rating5 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review
Video Quality
rating3 5 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review
Audio Quality
rating5 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review
Supplemental Materials
rating3 5 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

Click thumbnails for high-resolution 1920X1080p screen captures

More Screen Captures (18 Total)

(Screen captures are lightly compressed with lossy JPEG and thus are meant as a general representation of the content and do not fully reveal the capabilities of the Blu-ray format)

The Film

rating5 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

Comedian and director Jacques Tati’s 1967 film Playtime is without a doubt the filmmaker’s most technically accomplished creation of his career. The complex satire on modern life in the post-industrial world was and is a comedic extravaganza that lifts avant-garde cinema to new heights.

Taking years to complete, costs for Playtime would eventually come in at over fifteen million euros and would be a box office failure upon its eventual release in France. The disastrous reception by audiences would bankrupt Tati.

The film’s scarce plot revolves around Tati’s famous character, Monsieur Hulot arriving in Paris to meet with a businessman Monsieur Giffard (Georges Montant). Through a series of miscommunications and technical difficulties, Hulot finds himself wandering through the impossibly complicated glass and steel imbued structures of Paris, unable to connect with Giffard.

Playtime is filled with a number of gags and brilliantly choreographed movements that push the film forward. But, although visually stunning, one thing that seems to go unmentioned a lot when Playtime is spoken of is the jarring yet hilarious soundscape of the modern world that Tati created. Recorded to six tracks, glass doors “pong,” heels clickity-clack, gadgets beep and blip; Tati’s inventive aural landscape was not unlike something Stockhausen might have composed. Speaking of music, every time I have viewed Playtime in recent years, I can’t help but think of Radiohead’s OK Computer.

BDDefinitionplaytime e1080.thumbnail Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

Tati’s Playtime is a commentary on the failure to connect in the modern world; how the cold landscape of technology we have created around us has not only homogenized our society, but also served to alienate us from one another.  I always think of Thom Yorke’s nihilism and dystopian musings on OK Computer in songs like “Airbag,” or “Paranoid Android” when I see Barabara (Dennek), the young American tourist in Paris, hopelessly drifting through the modern structures searching for the old Paris.

Of course, Tati’s paranoia is tempered in Playtime with his inimitable sense of humour, and there are many wonderful examples of that which satirize the confusion of the modern world, such as the endlessly wandering platter of fish in the newly remodeled restaurant, which seems to never get served to anyone.

Playtime is pure genius. As social commentary, it is perhaps more relevant than ever today in this world of skyscrapers and social media. As comedy, it is even more ageless and timeless. It may have taken time for the true value of this work to be assessed, but genius is often not recognized immediately.

Video Quality

rating3 5 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

BDDefinitionplaytime k1080.thumbnail Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

Playtime was originally filmed on 65mm and intended by Tati for projection in theatres equipped with 70mm projection systems. As such, Playtime would be in a very high-resolution film format that, after restoration, would be more than capable of reproducing a stunning high definition image. This release from The Criterion Collection, however, uses a 1.85:1 AVC/MPEG-4 encoding scanned from the 35mm reduction internegative of Playtime’s restored 65mm interpositive.  So, although Playtime looks good and film-like, it does not look as good as it possibly could.

Surely, there are moments in this transfer where the detail for a transfer of a film this age is astounding, but noise, flicker, jitter, and grain sometimes becomes more pronounced. Don’t get me wrong, these things never reach a point where they are distracting, but they are noticeable at points. Background detail sometimes softens just a tad. One can’t help thinking that Playtime would have been better served being taken from its original 65mm source, rather than a 35mm duplicate.

Still, color reproduction of Tati’s cool, industrialized palette is strong and stable, with flesh tones a bit pale, but as they were intended. Black levels are not absolutely inky, but they are solid and shadow delineation is excellent. Playtime is still not in my opinion, one of the stronger transfers from The Criterion Collection, but as a high definition catalogue release it is still quite good.

Audio Quality

rating5 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

BDDefinitionplaytime q1080.thumbnail Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

Every bleep, blip, and blurb of Tati’s modern soundscape is reproduced effortlessly on this Blu-ray release, which provides both the original French and International release soundtracks in LPCM 2.0 (48kHz/24-bit). Both versions are nearly identical, with the latter only adding slightly more English dialogue for international audiences. The sound is clean, full, and dynamic with hardly any harshness or crackle. Tati’s original intention was to create an engulfing mix that would be the match of his 70mm vision, and on that Playtime succeeds, with panning of sound effects back and forth, and all manner of inventive sounds to capture the feel of the modern world. This release of Playtime is proof that sometimes two channels can be just as entertaining as four or more.

Supplemental Materials

rating3 5 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

BDDefinitionplaytime k1080.thumbnail Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

As is expected, Criterion does not disappoint with the supplemental materials for Playtime, all aimed at providing viewers with a deeper understanding of the film and its director, Jacques Tati. The one letdown is having all of the video extras provided in 1080i/60 upscaled from standard definition.

The supplements available on this release are:

  • Terry Jones Introduction (1.33:1; 1080i/60, upscaled; 0:06.17)
  • Selected Scene Commentary — Film historian Philip Kemp discusses selected scenes from the film:
    • A Triumph and a Disaster
    • An Abstract Ballet
    • Tativille/Satircal Ambivalence
    • Theatrics
    • Backstage/Structured Chaos
    • A Disenchanted Account
    • Ruin and a Recovered Reputation
  • Au-Delà de “Playtime” (1.33:1; 1080i/60, upscaled; 0:06.30) — A brief film documenting the production of Playtime.
  • Tati Story (1.33:1; 1080i/60, upscaled; 0:20.38) — A brief biography on the life and career of Jacques Tati.
  • Jacques Tati in M. Hulot’s Work” (1.33:1; 1080i/60; 0:49.28) — A 1976 BBC interview with Tati discussing hos work as a comedian and filmmaker and his character, Hulot.
  • Tati at the San Francisco Film Festival — Audio excerpts from from a Q&A session at the 1972 San Francisco Film Festival where the U.S. premiere of Playtime was hosted.
  • Sylvette Baudrot (1.33:1; 1080i/60, upscaled; 0:12.10) — Script supervisor, Sylvette Baudrot, recalls her work on Playtime.
  • Cours du Soir (1.33:1; 1080i/60; 0:27.41) — A short film from 1967 written by Jacques Tati and directed by Nicolas Rybowski in which Tati plays the instructor of a class studying mime.

The Definitive Word

Overall:

rating4 Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

BDDefinitionplaytime h1080.thumbnail Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

Playtime is indeed a playful film, but its title is delectably subversive. Forty-two-years ago, Jacques Tati gave the world a glimpse of the isolation and chaos that the technological juggernaut could produce in a humorous way. The world had no idea how spot-on he would be; it didn’t know how great a film he had given it either.

This Criterion release of Playtime looks above average for a catalogue release, but it is not as good as a 70mm film should look and not up to the normally high standards of Criterion either. Regardless, the bonus features and quality of the material make it well worth a purchase.

buynow Playtime [The Criterion Collection] Blu ray Review

Shop with us for more Blu-ray titles at Amazon.com

Tags: 1080p, Cover Art, Criterion Collection

Click for the Warner Bros. Online Shop-WBShop.com